| Pick | Pos | Player | Team | Selected By | |
| 01.01 | QB4 | Drew Brees | NO/4 | Flying Hellfish | k |
| 01.02 | RB1 | LaDainian Tomlinson | SD/7 | Team Juice | k |
| 01.03 | RB3 | Reggie Bush | NO/4 | Team WoJo | k |
| 01.04 | RB6 | Larry Johnson | KC/8 | Team Smith | k |
| 01.05 | RB2 | Steven Jackson | StL/9 | Drunken Sailors | k |
| 01.06 | RB5 | Frank Gore | SF/6 | Air JC | k |
| 01.07 | RB7 | Willie Parker | Pit/6 | Little Red Horse | k |
| 01.08 | RB8 | Joseph Addai | Ind/6 | Team Nookie | k |
| 01.09 | RB11 | Rudi Johnson | Cin/5 | Fantasy Superior | k |
| 01.10 | RB4 | Brian Westbrook | Phi/5 | Little Bastards | k |
| 01.11 | QB1 | Peyton Manning | Ind/6 | Kinger | k |
| 01.12 | RB12 | Laurence Maroney | NE/10 | Team Tang | k |
| 02.01 | RB10 | Shaun Alexander | Sea/8 | Team Tang | 1 |
| 02.02 | WR3 | Marvin Harrison | Ind/6 | Kinger | 2 |
| 02.03 | RB9 | Maurice Jones-Drew | Jac/4 | Little Bastards | 3 |
| 02.04 | RB18 | Edgerrin James | Ari/8 | Fantasy Superior | 4 |
| 02.05 | RB13 | Travis Henry | Den/6 | Team Nookie | 5 |
| 02.06 | WR1 | Chad Johnson | Cin/5 | Little Red Horse | 6 |
| 02.07 | RB14 | Ronnie Brown | Mia/9 | Air JC | 7 |
| 02.08 | RB16 | Willis McGahee | Bal/8 | Drunken Sailors | 8 |
| 02.09 | WR2 | Steve Smith | Car/7 | Team Smith | 9 |
| 02.10 | RB21 | Brandon Jacobs | NYG/9 | Team WoJo | 10 |
| 02.11 | RB15 | Clinton Portis | Was/4 | Team Juice | 11 |
| 02.12 | RB19 | Cedric Benson | Chi/9 | Flying Hellfish | 12 |
| 03.01 | RB23 | Thomas Jones | NYJ/10 | Flying Hellfish | 13 |
| 03.02 | QB2 | Carson Palmer | Cin/5 | Team Juice | 14 |
| 03.03 | QB3 | Tom Brady | NE/10 | Team WoJo | 15 |
| 03.04 | WR6 | Terrell Owens | Dal/8 | Team Smith | 16 |
| 03.05 | TE1 | Antonio Gates | SD/7 | Drunken Sailors | 17 |
| 03.06 | WR4 | Reggie Wayne | Ind/6 | Air JC | 18 |
| 03.07 | RB30 | DeShaun Foster | Car/7 | Little Red Horse | 19 |
| 03.08 | QB5 | Marc Bulger | StL/9 | Team Nookie | 20 |
| 03.09 | WR8 | Larry Fitzgerald | Ari/8 | Team Tang | 21 |
| 03.10 | WR5 | Torry Holt | StL/9 | Little Bastards | 22 |
| 03.11 | WR11 | Andre Johnson | Hou/10 | Kinger | 23 |
| 03.12 | QB6 | Donovan McNabb | Phi/5 | Team Tang | 24 |
| 04.01 | RB17 | Adrian Peterson | Min/5 | Team Tang | 25 |
| 04.02 | RB28 | Marion Barber III | Dal/8 | Kinger | 26 |
| 04.03 | WR7 | T.J. Houshmandzadeh | Cin/5 | Little Bastards | 27 |
| 04.04 | WR9 | Roy Williams | Det/6 | Fantasy Superior | 28 |
| 04.05 | WR12 | Lee Evans | Buf/6 | Team Nookie | 29 |
| 04.06 | WR13 | Donald Driver | GB/7 | Little Red Horse | 30 |
| 04.07 | WR10 | Anquan Boldin | Ari/8 | Air JC | 31 |
| 04.08 | WR14 | Javon Walker | Den/6 | Drunken Sailors | 32 |
| 04.09 | RB26 | Marshawn Lynch | Buf/6 | Team Smith | 33 |
| 04.10 | WR25 | Randy Moss | NE/10 | Team Smith | 34 |
| 04.11 | RB20 | Cadillac Williams | TB/10 | Team Juice | 35 |
| 04.12 | WR15 | Marques Colston | NO/4 | Flying Hellfish | 36 |
| 05.01 | WR23 | Hines Ward | Pit/6 | Flying Hellfish | 37 |
| 05.02 | WR16 | Plaxico Burress | NYG/9 | Team Juice | 38 |
| 05.03 | WR24 | Reggie Brown | Phi/5 | Team WoJo | 39 |
| 05.04 | RB24 | Deuce McAllister | NO/4 | Team Smith | 40 |
| 05.05 | WR19 | Laveranues Coles | NYJ/10 | Drunken Sailors | 41 |
| 05.06 | TE3 | Todd Heap | Bal/8 | Air JC | 42 |
| 05.07 | WR22 | Deion Branch | Sea/8 | Little Red Horse | 43 |
| 05.08 | TE2 | Jeremy Shockey | NYG/9 | Team Nookie | 44 |
| 05.09 | WR27 | Chris Chambers | Mia/9 | Fantasy Superior | 45 |
| 05.10 | TE4 | Tony Gonzalez | KC/8 | Little Bastards | 46 |
| 05.11 | TE5 | Kellen Winslow Jr | Cle/7 | Kinger | 47 |
| 05.12 | WR21 | Santana Moss | Was/4 | Team Tang | 48 |
| 06.01 | TE10 | Alge Crumpler | Atl/8 | Team Tang | 49 |
| 06.02 | RB22 | Ahman Green | Hou/10 | Kinger | 50 |
| 06.03 | QB8 | Vince Young | Ten/4 | Little Bastards | 51 |
| 06.04 | WR17 | Braylon Edwards | Cle/7 | Fantasy Superior | 52 |
| 06.05 | RB40 | Brandon Jackson | GB/7 | Team Nookie | 53 |
| 06.06 | RB27 | Tatum Bell | Det/6 | Little Red Horse | 54 |
| 06.07 | RB31 | Jamal Lewis | Cle/7 | Air JC | 55 |
| 06.08 | QB12 | Jon Kitna | Det/6 | Drunken Sailors | 56 |
| 06.09 | TE6 | Vernon Davis | SF/6 | Team Smith | 57 |
| 06.10 | WR18 | Calvin Johnson | Det/6 | Team WoJo | 58 |
| 06.11 | WR20 | Jerricho Cotchery | NYJ/10 | Team Juice | 59 |
| 06.12 | RB25 | Jerious Norwood | Atl/8 | Flying Hellfish | 60 |
| 07.01 | QB7 | Philip Rivers | SD/7 | Flying Hellfish | 61 |
| 07.02 | TE7 | Chris Cooley | Was/4 | Team Juice | 62 |
| 07.03 | RB35 | Julius Jones | Dal/8 | Team WoJo | 63 |
| 07.04 | QB9 | Tony Romo | Dal/8 | Team Smith | 64 |
| 07.05 | RB29 | LaMont Jordan | Oak/5 | Drunken Sailors | 65 |
| 07.06 | RB37 | Chester Taylor | Min/5 | Air JC | 66 |
| 07.07 | TE9 | Ben Watson | NE/10 | Little Red Horse | 67 |
| 07.08 | WR26 | Mark Clayton | Bal/8 | Team Nookie | 68 |
| 07.09 | RB33 | DeAngelo Williams | Car/7 | Fantasy Superior | 69 |
| 07.10 | RB41 | Kevin Jones | Det/6 | Little Bastards | 70 |
| 07.11 | RB39 | LenDale White | Ten/4 | Kinger | 71 |
| 07.12 | WR31 | Vincent Jackson | SD/7 | Team Tang | 72 |
| 08.01 | TE8 | Jason Witten | Dal/8 | Fantasy Superior | 73 |
| 08.02 | WR29 | Bernard Berrian | Chi/9 | Kinger | 74 |
| 08.03 | DEF1 | Chicago | Chi/9 | Little Bastards | 75 |
| 08.04 | QB14 | Matt Hasselbeck | Sea/8 | Fantasy Superior | 76 |
| 08.05 | RB32 | Fred Taylor | Jac/4 | Team Nookie | 77 |
| 08.06 | QB10 | Jay Cutler | Den/6 | Little Red Horse | 78 |
| 08.07 | QB11 | Ben Roethlisberger | Pit/6 | Air JC | 79 |
| 08.08 | QB13 | Matt Leinart | Ari/8 | Drunken Sailors | 80 |
| 08.09 | QB15 | Eli Manning | NYG/9 | Team Smith | 81 |
| 08.10 | TE12 | Dallas Clark | Ind/6 | Team WoJo | 82 |
| 08.11 | RB34 | Ladell Betts | Was/4 | Team Juice | 83 |
| 08.12 | TE15 | Randy McMichael | StL/9 | Flying Hellfish | 84 |
| 09.01 | WR37 | Terry Glenn | Dal/8 | Flying Hellfish | 85 |
| 09.02 | WR30 | Santonio Holmes | Pit/6 | Team Juice | 86 |
| 09.03 | DEF2 | Baltimore | Bal/8 | Team WoJo | 87 |
| 09.04 | QB19 | Jake Delhomme | Car/7 | Team Smith | 88 |
| 09.05 | RB47 | Chris Brown | Ten/4 | Drunken Sailors | 89 |
| 09.06 | QB16 | Alex Smith | SF/6 | Air JC | 90 |
| 09.07 | RB36 | Leon Washington | NYJ/10 | Little Red Horse | 91 |
| 09.08 | WR28 | Joey Galloway | TB/10 | Team Nookie | 92 |
| 09.09 | QB23 | Chad Pennington | NYJ/10 | Fantasy Superior | 93 |
| 09.10 | RB38 | Vernand Morency | GB/7 | Little Bastards | 94 |
| 09.11 | QB17 | Brett Favre | GB/7 | Kinger | 95 |
| 09.12 | RB44 | Warrick Dunn | Atl/8 | Team Tang | 96 |
| 10.01 | QB25 | Matt Schaub | Hou/10 | Team Tang | 97 |
| 10.02 | DEF6 | Minnesota | Min/5 | Kinger | 98 |
| 10.03 | WR32 | Darrell Jackson | SF/6 | Little Bastards | 99 |
| 10.04 | DEF7 | San Diego | SD/7 | Fantasy Superior | 100 |
| 10.05 | WR44 | Muhsin Muhammad | Chi/9 | Team Nookie | 101 |
| 10.06 | QB21 | Rex Grossman | Chi/9 | Little Red Horse | 102 |
| 10.07 | WR38 | Donte Stallworth | NE/10 | Air JC | 103 |
| 10.08 | DEF3 | New England | NE/10 | Drunken Sailors | 104 |
| 10.09 | WR46 | Devery Henderson | NO/4 | Team Smith | 105 |
| 10.10 | RB48 | Michael Turner | SD/7 | Team WoJo | 106 |
| 10.11 | QB20 | J.P. Losman | Buf/6 | Team Juice | 107 |
| 10.12 | TE13 | L.J. Smith | Phi/5 | Flying Hellfish | 108 |
| 11.01 | DEF5 | Denver | Den/6 | Flying Hellfish | 109 |
| 11.02 | WR33 | D.J. Hackett | Sea/8 | Team Juice | 110 |
| 11.03 | QB26 | Jeff Garcia | TB/10 | Team WoJo | 111 |
| 11.04 | PK1 | Adam Vinatieri | Ind/6 | Team Smith | 112 |
| 11.05 | WR35 | Greg Jennings | GB/7 | Drunken Sailors | 113 |
| 11.06 | WR41 | Eddie Kennison | KC/8 | Air JC | 114 |
| 11.07 | DEF8 | Carolina | Car/7 | Little Red Horse | 115 |
| 11.08 | QB22 | Steve McNair | Bal/8 | Team Nookie | 116 |
| 11.09 | WR42 | Kevin Curtis | Phi/5 | Fantasy Superior | 117 |
| 11.10 | QB32 | Damon Huard | KC/8 | Little Bastards | 118 |
| 11.11 | WR34 | Isaac Bruce | StL/9 | Kinger | 119 |
| 11.12 | TE14 | Owen Daniels | Hou/10 | Team Tang | 120 |
| 12.01 | PK8 | Nate Kaeding | SD/7 | Team Tang | 121 |
| 12.02 | TE17 | Desmond Clark | Chi/9 | Kinger | 122 |
| 12.03 | PK2 | Shayne Graham | Cin/5 | Little Bastards | 123 |
| 12.04 | PK7 | Jeff Wilkins | StL/9 | Fantasy Superior | 124 |
| 12.05 | TE11 | Heath Miller | Pit/6 | Team Nookie | 125 |
| 12.06 | PK13 | Neil Rackers | Ari/8 | Little Red Horse | 126 |
| 12.07 | QB24 | Byron Leftwich | Jac/4 | Air JC | 127 |
| 12.08 | WR40 | Jerry Porter | Oak/5 | Drunken Sailors | 128 |
| 12.09 | DEF24 | Jacksonville | Jac/4 | Team Smith | 129 |
| 12.10 | WR73 | Matt Jones | Jac/4 | Team WoJo | 130 |
| 12.11 | TE18 | Marcus Pollard | Sea/8 | Team Juice | 131 |
| 12.12 | QB27 | Tarvaris Jackson | Min/5 | Flying Hellfish | 132 |
| 13.01 | PK6 | Matt Stover | Bal/8 | Flying Hellfish | 133 |
| 13.02 | QB18 | Jason Campbell | Was/4 | Team Juice | 134 |
| 13.03 | PK5 | Stephen Gostkowski | NE/10 | Team WoJo | 135 |
| 13.04 | RB42 | Michael Pittman | TB/10 | Team Smith | 136 |
| 13.05 | DEF14 | Pittsburgh | Pit/6 | Drunken Sailors | 137 |
| 13.06 | TE16 | Bo Scaife | Ten/4 | Air JC | 138 |
| 13.07 | TE20 | Daniel Graham | Den/6 | Little Red Horse | 139 |
| 13.08 | PK4 | Robbie Gould | Chi/9 | Team Nookie | 140 |
| 13.09 | TE27 | Eric Johnson | NO/4 | Fantasy Superior | 141 |
| 13.10 | WR45 | Derrick Mason | Bal/8 | Little Bastards | 142 |
| 13.11 | PK3 | Jason Elam | Den/6 | Kinger | 143 |
| 13.12 | WR55 | Drew Bennett | StL/9 | Team Tang | 144 |
| 14.01 | DEF4 | Miami | Mia/9 | Team Tang | 145 |
| 14.02 | DEF17 | Dallas | Dal/8 | Kinger | 146 |
| 14.03 | QB29 | Trent Green | Mia/9 | Little Bastards | 147 |
| 14.04 | RB67 | Najeh Davenport | Pit/6 | Fantasy Superior | 148 |
| 14.05 | DEF9 | Philadelphia | Phi/5 | Team Nookie | 149 |
| 14.06 | WR39 | Brandon Jones | Ten/4 | Little Red Horse | 150 |
| 14.07 | PK9 | Olindo Mare | NO/4 | Air JC | 151 |
| 14.08 | PK11 | Josh Brown | Sea/8 | Drunken Sailors | 152 |
| 14.09 | TE26 | David Martin | Mia/9 | Team Smith | 153 |
| 14.10 | TE25 | Alex Smith | TB/10 | Team WoJo | 154 |
| 14.11 | DEF11 | New York Giants | NYG/9 | Team Juice | 155 |
| 14.12 | RB57 | Mike Bell | Den/6 | Flying Hellfish | 156 |
| 15.01 | WR51 | Joe Horn | Atl/8 | Flying Hellfish | 157 |
| 15.02 | PK10 | Josh Scobee | Jac/4 | Team Juice | 158 |
| 15.03 | WR50 | Troy Williamson | Min/5 | Team WoJo | 159 |
| 15.04 | PK17 | John Kasay | Car/7 | Team Smith | 160 |
| 15.05 | QB31 | Charlie Frye | Cle/7 | Drunken Sailors | 161 |
| 15.06 | DEF19 | St. Louis | StL/9 | Air JC | 162 |
| 15.07 | DEF13 | Buffalo | Buf/6 | Little Red Horse | 163 |
| 15.08 | QB28 | Joey Harrington | Atl/8 | Team Nookie | 164 |
| 15.09 | QB34 | Daunte Culpepper | Oak/5 | Fantasy Superior | 165 |
| 15.10 | TE29 | Ben Utecht | Ind/6 | Little Bastards | 166 |
| 15.11 | PK14 | Joe Nedney | SF/6 | Kinger | 167 |
| 15.12 | DEF12 | Cincinnati | Cin/5 | Team Tang | 168 |
| 16.01 | PK12 | David Akers | Phi/5 | Team Tang | 169 |
| 16.02 | RB50 | Anthony Thomas | Buf/6 | Kinger | 170 |
| 16.03 | PK15 | Jason Hanson | Det/6 | Little Bastards | 171 |
| 16.04 | DEF16 | Arizona | Ari/8 | Fantasy Superior | 172 |
| 16.05 | DEF10 | Green Bay | GB/7 | Team Nookie | 173 |
| 16.06 | QB35 | Brady Quinn | Cle/7 | Little Red Horse | 174 |
| 16.07 | DEF18 | Tennessee | Ten/4 | Air JC | 175 |
| 16.08 | PK19 | Mike Nugent | NYJ/10 | Drunken Sailors | 176 |
| 16.09 | DEF28 | Detroit | Det/6 | Team Smith | 177 |
| 16.10 | DEF25 | Indianapolis | Ind/6 | Team WoJo | 178 |
| 16.11 | PK16 | Lawrence Tynes | NYG/9 | Team Juice | 179 |
| 16.12 | DEF26 | Kansas City | KC/8 | Flying Hellfish | 180 |
| 17.01 | PK22 | Jay Feely | Mia/9 | Flying Hellfish | 181 |
| 17.02 | DEF21 | Atlanta | Atl/8 | Team Juice | 182 |
| 17.03 | PK33 | Martin Gramatica | Dal/8 | Team WoJo | 183 |
| 17.04 | QB30 | Brodie Croyle | KC/8 | Team WoJo | 184 |
| 17.05 | TE24 | Greg Olsen | Chi/9 | Drunken Sailors | 185 |
| 17.06 | PK18 | Jeff Reed | Pit/6 | Air JC | 186 |
| 17.07 | PK21 | Rian Lindell | Buf/6 | Little Red Horse | 187 |
| 17.08 | PK27 | Ryan Longwell | Min/5 | Team Nookie | 188 |
| 17.09 | PK26 | Rob Bironas | Ten/4 | Fantasy Superior | 189 |
| 17.10 | DEF15 | San Francisco | SF/6 | Little Bastards | 190 |
| 17.11 | QB38 | David Garrard | Jac/4 | Kinger | 191 |
| 17.12 | QB9999 | Kevin Kolb | Phi/5 | Team Tang | 192 |