| Pick | Pos | Player | Team | Selected By |
| Keeper | RB1 | LaDainian Tomlinson | SD/10 | Team Juice - Juice |
| Keeper | RB6 | Clinton Portis | Was/7 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| Keeper | RB9 | Fred Taylor | Jac/9 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| Keeper | RB2 | Priest Holmes | KC/5 | Juggers - Jugs |
| Keeper | RB14 | Domanick Davis | Hou/7 | Smitty - Smith |
| Keeper | RB4 | Ahman Green | GB/9 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| Keeper | RB16 | Corey Dillon | NE/3 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| Keeper | QB1 | Daunte Culpepper | Min/4 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| Keeper | RB7 | Shaun Alexander | Sea/4 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| Keeper | RB13 | Michael Bennett | Min/4 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| Keeper | WR1 | Marvin Harrison | Ind/6 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| Keeper | WR3 | Torry Holt | StL/8 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 1.01 | RB3 | Deuce McAllister | NO/8 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 1.02 | RB5 | Edgerrin James | Ind/6 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 1.03 | WR2 | Randy Moss | Min/4 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 1.04 | RB10 | Jamal Lewis | Bal/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 1.05 | RB19 | Rudi Johnson | Cin/5 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 1.06 | WR4 | Terrell Owens | Phi/5 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 1.07 | QB2 | Peyton Manning | Ind/6 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 1.08 | RB20 | Marshall Faulk | StL/8 | Smitty - Smith |
| 1.09 | RB8 | Kevan Barlow | SF/7 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 1.10 | RB11 | Brian Westbrook | Phi/5 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 1.11 | QB6 | Michael Vick | Atl/9 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 1.12 | RB12 | Tiki Barber | NYG/6 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 2.01 | RB24 | Stephen Davis | Car/3 | Smitty - Smith |
| 2.02 | RB27 | Charlie Garner | TB/8 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 2.03 | QB3 | Donovan McNabb | Phi/5 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 2.04 | RB21 | Duce Staley | Pit/7 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 2.05 | WR5 | Chad Johnson | Cin/5 | Smitty - Smith |
| 2.06 | RB17 | Travis Henry | Buf/3 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 2.07 | RB15 | Thomas Jones | Chi/5 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 2.08 | WR6 | Hines Ward | Pit/7 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 2.09 | WR10 | Santana Moss | NYJ/3 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 2.10 | RB25 | Kevin Jones - R | Det/4 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 2.11 | RB23 | Quentin Griffin | Den/10 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 2.12 | RB18 | Curtis Martin | NYJ/3 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 3.01 | QB5 | Trent Green | KC/5 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 3.02 | QB7 | Steve McNair | Ten/9 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 3.03 | WR7 | Derrick Mason | Ten/9 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 3.04 | WR9 | Steve Smith | Car/3 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 3.05 | QB4 | Matt Hasselbeck | Sea/4 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 3.06 | TE2 | Todd Heap | Bal/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 3.07 | WR15 | Laveranues Coles | Was/7 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 3.08 | RB22 | Chris Brown | Ten/9 | Smitty - Smith |
| 3.09 | WR16 | Joe Horn | NO/8 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 3.10 | TE1 | Tony Gonzalez | KC/5 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 3.11 | WR11 | Darrell Jackson | Sea/4 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 3.12 | QB8 | Aaron Brooks | NO/8 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 4.01 | WR8 | Eric Moulds | Buf/3 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 4.02 | WR20 | Charles Rogers | Det/4 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 4.03 | WR18 | Koren Robinson | Sea/4 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 4.04 | WR12 | Andre Johnson | Hou/7 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 4.05 | WR27 | Javon Walker | GB/9 | Smitty - Smith |
| 4.06 | WR13 | Chris Chambers | Mia/10 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 4.07 | WR19 | Peerless Price | Atl/9 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 4.08 | WR21 | Rod Smith | Den/10 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 4.09 | RB29 | Lee Suggs | Cle/8 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 4.10 | RB37 | Eddie George | Dal/4 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 4.11 | WR14 | Jimmy Smith | Jac/9 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 4.12 | TE5 | Randy McMichael | Mia/10 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 5.01 | WR17 | Jerry Porter | Oak/10 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 5.02 | RB26 | Warrick Dunn | Atl/9 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 5.03 | TE3 | Jeremy Shockey | NYG/6 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 5.04 | QB9 | Tom Brady | NE/3 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 5.05 | RB34 | T.J. Duckett | Atl/9 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 5.06 | WR30 | Keyshawn Johnson | Dal/4 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 5.07 | RB33 | Julius Jones - R | Dal/4 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 5.08 | WR22 | Amani Toomer | NYG/6 | Smitty - Smith |
| 5.09 | WR26 | Plaxico Burress | Pit/7 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 5.10 | QB13 | Chad Pennington | NYJ/3 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 5.11 | RB31 | Tyrone Wheatley | Oak/10 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 5.12 | WR23 | Isaac Bruce | StL/8 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 6.01 | RB30 | Moe Williams | Min/4 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 6.02 | TE4 | Kellen Winslow - R | Cle/8 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 6.03 | RB28 | Travis Minor | Mia/10 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 6.04 | QB12 | Marc Bulger | StL/8 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 6.05 | QB11 | Brett Favre | GB/9 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 6.06 | TE8 | Freddie Jones | Ari/6 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 6.07 | TE6 | Alge Crumpler | Atl/9 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 6.08 | RB39 | DeShaun Foster | Car/3 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 6.09 | RB32 | Steven Jackson - R | StL/8 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 6.10 | WR32 | Donte' Stallworth | NO/8 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 6.11 | QB17 | Jake Plummer | Den/10 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 6.12 | WR35 | Deion Branch | NE/3 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 7.01 | QB15 | Byron Leftwich | Jac/9 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 7.02 | TE14 | Antonio Gates | SD/10 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 7.03 | WR24 | Larry Fitzgerald - R | Ari/6 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 7.04 | WR28 | Reggie Wayne | Ind/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 7.05 | WR55 | Roy Williams - R | Det/4 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 7.06 | QB10 | Jeff Garcia | Cle/8 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 7.07 | WR60 | Peter Warrick | Cin/5 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 7.08 | TE10 | Boo Williams | NO/8 | Smitty - Smith |
| 7.09 | WR34 | Justin McCareins | NYJ/3 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 7.10 | WR25 | Brandon Lloyd | SF/7 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 7.11 | DEF2 | Baltimore | Bal/6 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 7.12 | TE7 | Daniel Graham | NE/3 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 8.01 | RB35 | Willis McGahee | Buf/3 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 8.02 | WR29 | Joey Galloway | TB/8 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 8.03 | WR33 | Muhsin Muhammad | Car/3 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 8.04 | TE13 | Dallas Clark | Ind/6 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 8.05 | WR48 | Ashley Lelie | Den/10 | Smitty - Smith |
| 8.06 | QB24 | Joey Harrington | Det/4 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 8.07 | WR43 | Donald Driver | GB/9 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 8.08 | TE18 | L.J. Smith | Phi/5 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 8.09 | PK1 | Mike Vanderjagt | Ind/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 8.10 | RB49 | Ron Dayne | NYG/6 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 8.11 | DEF1 | New England | NE/3 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 8.12 | DEF5 | Philadelphia | Phi/5 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 9.01 | RB89 | Tatum Bell - R | Den/10 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 9.02 | WR31 | Eddie Kennison | KC/5 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 9.03 | QB16 | David Carr | Hou/7 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 9.04 | RB70 | Chester Taylor | Bal/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 9.05 | RB48 | Lamont Jordan | NYJ/3 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 9.06 | QB19 | Jake Delhomme | Car/3 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 9.07 | WR37 | Terry Glenn | Dal/4 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 9.08 | QB22 | Brad Johnson | TB/8 | Smitty - Smith |
| 9.09 | QB18 | Carson Palmer | Cin/5 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 9.10 | PK2 | Jeff Wilkins | StL/8 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 9.11 | QB25 | Tommy Maddox | Pit/7 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 9.12 | PK3 | Jason Elam | Den/10 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 10.01 | WR40 | Andre' Davis | Cle/8 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 10.02 | WR58 | Kevin Dyson | SD/10 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 10.03 | RB45 | William Green | Cle/8 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 10.04 | TE15 | Bubba Franks | GB/9 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 10.05 | QB27 | Drew Bledsoe | Buf/3 | Smitty - Smith |
| 10.06 | TE12 | Jim Kleinsasser | Min/4 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 10.07 | PK5 | David Akers | Phi/5 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 10.08 | QB21 | Mark Brunell | Was/7 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 10.09 | QB20 | Josh McCown | Ari/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 10.10 | WR52 | Tyrone Calico | Ten/9 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 10.11 | WR39 | Rod Gardner | Was/7 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 10.12 | QB14 | Rich Gannon | Oak/10 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 11.01 | PK7 | Josh Brown | Sea/4 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 11.02 | RB59 | Antowain Smith | Ten/9 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 11.03 | DEF4 | Carolina | Car/3 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 11.04 | WR36 | Quincy Morgan | Cle/8 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 11.05 | WR53 | Drew Bennett | Ten/9 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 11.06 | DEF14 | Dallas | Dal/4 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 11.07 | RB38 | Emmitt Smith | Ari/6 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 11.08 | QB26 | Rex Grossman | Chi/5 | Smitty - Smith |
| 11.09 | RB36 | Richie Anderson | Dal/4 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 11.10 | QB23 | Tim Rattay | SF/7 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 11.11 | RB41 | Jerome Bettis | Pit/7 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 11.12 | DEF3 | Tampa Bay | TB/8 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 12.01 | WR41 | David Terrell | Chi/5 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 12.02 | TE17 | Marcus Pollard | Ind/6 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 12.03 | DEF6 | St.Louis | StL/8 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 12.04 | WR79 | Anquan Boldin | Ari/6 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 12.05 | TE16 | Erron Kinney | Ten/9 | Smitty - Smith |
| 12.06 | QB32 | Vinny Testaverde | Dal/4 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 12.07 | RB40 | Kevin Faulk | NE/3 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 12.08 | PK4 | Adam Vinatieri | NE/3 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 12.09 | QB28 | Kyle Boller | Bal/6 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 12.10 | QB31 | Eli Manning - R | NYG/6 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 12.11 | QB30 | Jay Fiedler | Mia/10 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 12.12 | TE9 | Desmond Clark | Chi/5 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 13.01 | PK9 | Jay Feely | Atl/9 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 13.02 | PK6 | Matt Stover | Bal/6 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 13.03 | TE19 | Byron Chamberlain | Den/10 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 13.04 | TE24 | Jerramy Stevens | Sea/4 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 13.05 | TE22 | Billy Miller | Hou/7 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 13.06 | QB43 | Kerry Collins | Oak/10 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 13.07 | DEF8 | Miami | Mia/10 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 13.08 | PK10 | Ryan Longwell | GB/9 | Smitty - Smith |
| 13.09 | PK20 | Jason Hanson | Det/4 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 13.10 | QB40 | Kurt Warner | NYG/6 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 13.11 | QB29 | Drew Brees | SD/10 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 13.12 | TE25 | Kyle Brady | Jac/9 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 14.01 | QB34 | Drew Henson - R | Dal/4 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 14.02 | PK14 | Joe Nedney | Ten/9 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 14.03 | TE11 | Jason Witten | Dal/4 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 14.04 | DEF23 | Buffalo | Buf/3 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 14.05 | DEF12 | Minnesota | Min/4 | Smitty - Smith |
| 14.06 | PK16 | Martin Gramatica | TB/8 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 14.07 | PK8 | Sebastian Janikowski | Oak/10 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 14.08 | PK15 | John Hall | Was/7 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 14.09 | PK11 | John Carney | NO/8 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 14.10 | PK17 | Morten Andersen | KC/5 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 14.11 | TE20 | Eric Johnson | SF/7 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 14.12 | DEF11 | Tennessee | Ten/9 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 15.01 | QB33 | AJ Feeley | Mia/10 | Little Red Horse - Jason |
| 15.02 | DEF18 | Denver | Den/10 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 15.03 | PK23 | Billy Cundiff | Dal/4 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 15.04 | DEF13 | Seattle | Sea/4 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 15.05 | DEF7 | Atlanta | Atl/9 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 15.06 | DEF16 | Pittsburgh | Pit/7 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 15.07 | PK31 | Neil Rackers | Ari/6 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 15.08 | PK13 | John Kasay | Car/3 | Smitty - Smith |
| 15.09 | PK24 | Paul Edinger | Chi/5 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 15.10 | PK12 | Aaron Elling | Min/4 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 15.11 | DEF10 | Kansas City | KC/5 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 15.12 | PK21 | Doug Brien | NYJ/3 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 16.01 | DEF9 | Green Bay | GB/9 | Team Juice - Juice |
| 16.02 | PK22 | Olindo Mare | Mia/10 | Team Nookie - Ben |
| 16.03 | DEF17 | NY Giants | NYG/6 | Little Bastards - Jon C |
| 16.04 | DEF20 | Indianapolis | Ind/6 | Juggers - Jugs |
| 16.05 | DEF15 | New Orleans | NO/8 | Smitty - Smith |
| 16.06 | DEF31 | Arizona | Ari/6 | Team Goo - Cutts |
| 16.07 | TE21 | Doug Jolley | Oak/10 | Wong's LD's - Wong |
| 16.08 | DEF19 | Washington | Was/7 | Team Tang - Jonny |
| 16.09 | DEF24 | Jacksonville | Jac/9 | Air JC - Jeremy |
| 16.10 | DEF32 | Houston | Hou/7 | Inside Straights - Mike V. |
| 16.11 | PK19 | Shayne Graham | Cin/5 | Flying Hellfish - Soumala |
| 16.12 | RB42 | Garrison Hearst | Den/10 | Little Red Horse - Jason |